How the Mountainfeet shop evolved…

This history of how Mountainfeet was started and then evolved into a footwear and foot health specialist shop was written by Si back in 2015.

We hope it’s of interest to anyone who shopped with us in either Oldham or Marsden – just bear in mind the article is written in the present tense and doesn’t reflect that Mountainfeet actually closed back in December 2022…

The shop floor and Gyp Collie – click for larger image.

My specialist outdoor footwear shop Mountainfeet wasn’t born as such, it evolved over time. In fact if ten years ago you’d have told me I’d be majoring in footwear sales and foot health solutions I’d have said you were having a laugh! But times change in ways we can’t always predict and by adapting to those changes we often find new directions in our working lives…

Mountainfeet is a small but highly specialised destination footwear retailer in the Pennine village of Marsden where I also happen to live. Our ethos is to attempt to provide the very best in service to committed outdoor enthusiasts who can see past the pile it high and sell it cheap temptation of the recent crop of internet and warehouse style stores.

To get to where we are now has been a financially and emotionally painful experience which started in 2002 when I bought into an ailing independent outdoor clothing and equipment shop called Paul Braithwaites in Oldham that had been almost brought to its knees by the foot and mouth epidemic of 2001. I had previously climbed and mountain biked with the owner and to keep what had been a well respected emporium trading he needed an injection of cash and new energy. I’d been an Alpine ski instructor for several years abroad and had a mountaineering background which he found useful in developing additional specialist areas of expertise within the shop.

For three years, Garry and I rubbed along famously in most ways, although we used to fall out with regard to technology and its employment within what Garry saw as a traditional small shop environment. Having also worked for many years in IT for IBM, my rationale was to utilise easily affordable computers and software not only for the usual back office tasks but also on the sales floor to bring us into the twenty first century. I wrote systems for ordering, EPOS and other labour saving aids. Could I persuade Garry as senior partner to implement them though? I think you already know the answer!

This was a source of slight irritation but one thing Garry had cleverly identified was that the heart of our shop through thick and thin seemed always to be our footwear room. However, I remember in the early days doing everything possible to steer clear of it and letting him or the other staff deal with boot and shoe sales – luckily, that fear of footwear wouldn’t last too long…

Anyway, ultimately Garry moved on to professional pastures new and I committed (for better or for worse!) to buying his share of the shop so we wouldn’t have to dissolve the business. In hindsight that might not have been the smartest move…

I think we can guess the rest given that this was around 2004… To be honest, at first things seemed fairly rosy. I had cultivated great staff, we dabbled in a couple of niche sports like ski mountaineering and our reputation grew. But I think the writing was on the wall for us in many ways. Bear in mind that at that time, we stocked a huge inventory – everything from tent pegs to skis and huge amounts of technical clothing which had to be forward ordered and produced a frightening financial commitment.

Still, we saw that the one constant through our ups and downs was our boot room and mused on this. My three full time staff and I sat down and decided that while our service selling footwear was polite and informed from a sporting angle, our fitting skills left something to be desired. We immediately decided to act on that and initially enrolled everyone on a Superfeet course which taught us a little more about foot physiology and galvanised our interest in biomechanics of the lower limbs.

From there, our experience and reputation grew. We developed relationships with a couple of local podiatrists and took further training with them. We questioned and debated medical issues and fine tuned a new procedure for fitting footwear which we documented for potential customers on our website. Key to this methodology was the principle that everyone buying shoes should receive an informal biomechanical foot health appraisal from us. To provide the credentials we needed and develop confidence within our customer base we took more training which culminated in one of our staff, Phil, achieving a podiatry degree and two others (myself included) qualifying as foot health practitioners.

Now customers were visiting from further and further away as our service offering evolved to more expert levels. It seemed as if we’d found the vital ingredient that would help us prosper, where by now, so many other independents like us were closing or going downhill. And then, just as we thought we’d bucked the recession, the axe blade fell hard on our neck…

After winning our Town Council’s retailer of the year award twice on the trot as well as a national retailing award, the euphoria turned to dread when the same Council announced plans for the redevelopment of our town centre and the introduction of a Metrolink system. Despite protestations from all manner of businesses located in Oldham that many of us wouldn’t survive the four years of disruption, the works went ahead and to cut a long, drawn out story short, we announced our closure with debts and a heavy heart in January 2012 having outlasted several other High Street players.

What’s this tale of woe got to do with shoe fitting you may ask? Well, once I’d realised trading in our present format and location wasn’t an option I started thinking. One conclusion that hadn’t changed in over ten years was that footwear was the hub of our shop. But now there was another realisation. We had grown enough of a reputation in our field that we could (probably) exist selling outdoor footwear alone and in an out of town location. The phrase, “build it and they will come” kept echoing around my head and I spent weeks looking for a suitable low rent property we could start the process from. After weeks of fruitless searching in the vicinity of Oldham, Ashton and Stalybridge, I suddenly changed tack completely and found a small but appealing mill building in my home village of Marsden. The lease was signed in an instant and then the hard light of day showed itself. The building was knackered! Still, I have some very loyal and enterprising friends and with their help and lots of midnight oil burned, we rebuilt our new acquisition. The joy of this was that I could design pretty much the ideal internal layout conducive to our purposes.

We opened on deadline at the start of February 2012 with the paint still drying and engrained on my fingers and for one unworthy moment I thought, “will anyone actually come?” But they did, and they’ve kept coming for nearly three years in ever increasing numbers to experience an offering of expertise I honestly believe is unique in our field.

Last year, I realised a long standing ambition by opening a foot health clinic staffed by a qualified podiatrist within the shop. We had always referred customers where necessary to a couple of local podiatry clinics – now we can keep those referrals in-house when an issue requiring more skilled intervention is required.

Other outdoor shops have been canny enough to develop an improved service in this area and there are more trained footwear staff than ever thanks to associations like the Society of Shoe Fitters and retailer courses provided by manufacturers. Some of the more prestigious emporiums have “guest podiatrists” but these are often just half a day’s pop up presences and not a substitute for an in house foot health clinic such as we now have.

Our mission is to lessen the guess work involved in much outdoor footwear purchasing and to measure and assess each and every customer of ours to obtain not only the appropriate genre of footwear but also of course the correct fit. Our mantra is to listen to the customers needs and observe carefully the many variables they present with both physically and mentally. To that end, we don’t dictate when a fitting rule is contravened at a customers request – just guide and advise. We might for instance fit and lace the footwear of a young, technical mountaineer requiring performance very differently to that of an elderly dog walker striving for pure comfort!

I also insist that customers are all treated fairly and with the courtesy I myself would like to find if I were shopping. Most small shops like ours face supply and stocking issues, often due to cash flow. It’s very tempting to try to offload what you’ve got on the premises even if it’s not necessarily the right thing. Sure, you’ll make a sale and put some cash in the till. But get found out and you quite rightly won’t see those folk again. If your reputation is such that your customer trusts you implicitly, he or she will wait for the right product to be ordered – particularly when you impress upon them they’re not beholden to buy if the fit’s not right. We have many manufacturer accounts and our customer order database typically has between 20 and 30 orders in progress. Sometimes we make no money at all on an esoteric order but the goodwill generated from that one transaction is more than the big supermarket players will ever enjoy!

As we’ve acquired experience, we’ve also got to know our products better and better. There’s very little guesswork when bringing out footwear for a customer to try, so usually they walk away with the first or second pair they are shown. At the end of the day that saves time for us and confusion for them – it just needs confidence on our staff’s part. Most customers are also happy for us to narrow the choice right down – even with over eighty different footwear models in stock, only a handful will fit correctly and be suitable for a particular use. We supply a huge range of different orthotics and footbeds but only suggest their inclusion in footwear if appropriate – I personally think the current trend for supplying a supportive foot bed as an add on sale is slightly worrying!

Our core customers now tend to be the more mature folk. They’re the ones starting to experience foot health woes and they need and appreciate expert attention. Of course, if we could attract the younger and more active outdoor enthusiasts, we could help prevent some of the problems our older customers present with!

We charge normal manufacturers RRP’s and at our previous shop, customers would grumble and agitate for discounts. That rarely happens these days as we are confident in the massive added value we give with our biomechanical appraisals and the solutions we offer.

We’ve found the main trick is to work to but not above the limits of our expertise, to carry on taking advice from other professionals and to use common sense and observation when providing fitting solutions. Above all, we listen to our customers…

Three years on from opening Mountainfeet in Marsden, we are just about to renew our lease again and through the numerous customer recommendations we receive, business is still growing. The formula I’ve used to get here has been mainly one of hard graft and adaptation to the market and it will work for other small footwear shops provided they have the passion we have. We’re never likely to be rich but to still be trading successfully as a small independent in this day and age and have immense job satisfaction is reward enough for me…

Si’s latest Winter Spine kit list

A lot of potential Spine event participants ask about kit – it’s a huge subject. Here, I’ve listed the mandatory items that have to be carried and the specific articles I used. At the end, there’s an additional list detailing the extra kit I felt I needed to cope with the vicious Winter conditions encountered on the route, plus stuff in the drop bag to make check point life easier.

Clothing and shoes worn at the start:
Scarpa Ribelle Run Kalibra G trail shoes*
Sidas 3Feet Mid footbeds
Montane Phase Light waterproof jacket*
Rab Firewall waterproof trousers*
OMM Core Plus Hoodie
Montane Terra trousers*
Helly Hansen Lifa Stripe crew long sleeve top (base layer)*
Paramo Cambio boxer shorts (underwear)
Bridgedale Lightweight Merino Comfort Boot socks*
Bridgedale Knee Length Midweight Storm socks
Rab Filament beanie

*Mandatory (generic) item

And carrying:
Black Diamond Distance FLZ carbon running poles

Mandatory kit applying to every competitor:
Montane Trailblazer 30 pack modified to carry OMM Chest Pouch
(Exped 50 litre rolltop waterproof pack liner)*
Silva Expedition 4 compass
Harvey’s North and South maps of Pennine Way
Garmin eTrex 32X GPS
Orange Marine Safety whistle
Bolle Cobra safety goggles with strap
Fenix HM65R-T v2.0 headtorch
(SPARE Fenix 4,000 mAh battery)*
Montane Logo Beanie hat
Montane Power Stretch touch gloves
Montane Montane Respond Dry Line insulated waterproof gloves
Montane Montane Respond Dry Line insulated waterproof mitts
SPARE Bridgedale Lightweight Merino Comfort Boot socks
Buff neck warmer
Montane Dart XT long sleeve top (base layer)
Montane Dart XT long johns (base layer)
Rab Photon insulated jacket
Kahtoola Microspikes
Summit to Sea Spark II sleeping bag (superseded by the Spark Ultralight -1)
Alpkit Numo sleeping mat
Alpkit Hunka bivvy bag
Alpkit Kraku stove
Alpkit MytiMug 400ml titanium mug
MSR Piezzo stove lighter
MSR Folding Utensils Spork
iPhone SE in Ortleib waterproof pouch
Alpkit Tau rechargeable red LED light
The Tent Lab Deuce titanium trowel
Toilet kit – Dog waste bags and tissues
Medical kit/personal first aid kit with scissors as specified by Spine medics
(Various Exped rolltop waterproof bags)*
Platypus Platy 2 litre bottle
(Montane Water Ultraflask 500Ml with long straw top)*
(Salomon Soft Flask XA Filter 490ML)*
Food as specified (1,500 calories) including SIS gels

*Items in brackets not mandatory but virtually essential

Extra stuff in drop bag or carried in addition to the above mandatory kit:
Montane Phase XT waterproof jacket
Rab Sil Poncho
Rab Bergen waterproof trousers
Montane Minimus lightweight waterproof trousers
Rab Generator insulated jacket
Rab Vapour-Rise Alpine Light Jacket
Montane Slipstream thermal running tights
Scarpa Ribelle Run Kalibra G trail shoes
Scott RC running cap
Black Diamond Distance Z aluminium running poles
North Face Pamir Windstopper gloves
Montane Extreme mitts
Victorinox Alox SD knife
Apple iPod shuffle plus headphones and charging cable
Alpkit Juice Boost 5,000mAh power bank
Adaptors: USB C to Lightning, USB Micro and Garmin Fenix (from Amazon)
Rossignol face mask (otherwise in drop bag)
Paracetamol and codeine sufficient for the duration
Vaseline lip balm
Gurney Goo for rubbing areas and potential blisters
SPARE Montane Power Stretch touch gloves
SPARE Montane hooded long sleeve top (base layer)
SPARE Paramo Cambio boxer shorts (underwear)
SPARE Bridgedale Knee Length Midweight Storm socks x 3
SPARE Bridgedale Lightweight Merino Comfort Boot socks x 3
SPARE foodstuffs to top back to 1,500 calories at CP’s
SPARE SIS gels
SPARE laces (already attached to compass and whistle in pack)
SPARE Petzl Swift headtorch
SPARE Petzl Swift battery
SPARE Alpkit Blip rear LED light
Bloc Titan Photochromic glasses with reading inserts
Additional mandatory first aid supplies
Footcare kit
High Five electrolyte tablets

And for charging at check points:
Anker USB mains plug
Leads for USB C, USB Micro, Lightning and Garmin Fenix

And for sleeping in at check points:
Cumulus Quantum 450 sleeping bag
Alpkit Drift pillow
(Sleeping mat recommended as beds aren’t always available)

And for changing into and travelling home in:
SPARE OMM Core Plus Hoodie
Fleece trousers
Crocs

 

Winter Spine MRT Challenger North

Where to start with this one?

It’s become apparent that there’s some real interest from friends and family about January’s experience on the Winter Spine MRT Challenger North race.

Rather than trot out the same stories time and time again and running the risk of becoming a Spine bore, it’s probably best just to write down what I remember of the event and how I coped with it at the time. That way, if folk genuinely want more details, then they’re here in black and white. And there’s always the possibility that they’ll provide a little chunk of inspiration or maybe some technical advice for anyone diving headfirst into the world of Spine racing themselves.

For anyone struggling to read the article on a small screen, there’s a text only PDF version here.

With the completion of the MRT Challenger North and a third out of three events finish, it feels as if I’ve reached the end of my personal Spine journey. As mountain rescue team members, we’re privileged to have a generous subsidised entry into either Challenger events. This means that folk like me with no previous pedigree or indeed interest in ultra distance events can take a punt without committing too much on the financial side (although more thoughts on that later!!!).

Oldham Mountain Rescue Team are firmly embedded into the history of the Spine Series Races. One of our most stalwart members, Matt Torr, has not only competed in Winter series races but also was the first to moot a separate event for the teams who had traditionally provided support along the Pennine Way. Our present team leader, Dave Wyatt, was an early full Winter Spine Race finisher and a veteran of Challenger South events as are several other colleagues. Over the years, many of us have learned about the Spine through long shifts up on the A62 crossing point, handing out brews and Park Cake nibbles, refilling water bottles and generally trying to motivate tired racers with banter, Christmas lights and cow bells!

Inevitably, some of us have gone on to think, “could I do this?” Well, the only way to find out is to enter, but thereby lay the problem for me. With some joint and tendon issues which have since been diagnosed as a rheumatoid condition, it felt like an almost impossible ask to attempt the full distance race of 268 miles and a massive risk committing over a thousand pounds to an entry.

Lo and behold, the Winter Spine Sprint came along in the nick of time – a feasible 46 mile snap shot of the full event without any of the logistical baggage such as checkpoints or drop bags to worry about. In January 2023 the race started from Edale in damp but improving conditions and 13.5 hours later I was collecting that first coveted Spine medal at Hebden Bridge.

Itch fully scratched? Obviously not!

Jacob’s Ladder – MRT Challenger South 2024

Several weeks later, the opportunity to enter the 108 mile Winter Spine MRT Challenger South event was too good to miss. Spin forward nearly twelve months and the start of the race arrived. We were all lucky to be blessed with great weather and ground conditions on the first day although subzero temperatures, high winds and painful heel bursitis on the second made it necessary to go into limp mode for the final sixty miles. I was lucky to buddy up with Wes Cole who’d also hurt himself and with just two good legs between us we pushed each other to the finish in Hawes. Definitely remember saying “never again” to entering a Spine series event but a few weeks later when entries for the following winter went live I was sucked back in, this time on the Challenger North…

One thing I sussed out after the Challenger South is that it’s a big step up from the Sprint in several ways. Apart from the attrition of the extra mileage, there are logistical, nutritional and tactical matters to address plus the nightmare of sleep deprivation. The Challenger North at 160 miles, ups the game even more with multiple checkpoints and more responsibility to yourself to treat blistering feet and other injuries that can threaten to stop the job.

At this point I’d like to mention some folk who made getting to the 2025 start line in Hardraw possible. I’ve known David Riley from Beyond Wild Adventures for many years and he’s a fixture on the Spine scene having completed several events including two full Winter Spine races. Partly down to his supremely positive outlook on everything and also his professional role as a Mountain Leader, he motivates and inspires by example. Training with him over the last couple of years has taught me a thing or two about going big in the hills and together with his lovely wife Amanda and border collie Flinty, we’ve had some memorable days (and nights) out together in the Pennines where we all live.

Ryan Townrow

Ryan Townrow is a friend and neighbour in Marsden plus a bit of a legend in the local fell running scene. His interest in the Spine was started when I finished the Sprint in 2023 and he completed 2024’s event in a smoking time. However, when he saw the state of Wes after his Challenger South effort when we had to lift him out of our car, he declared he’d never do it himself! But yeah, you’ve guessed it – he couldn’t help himself and completed this years 110 mile event in diabolical ground conditions. We’ve not trained much together because of individual injuries but have constantly been at each other’s houses sorting kit out and making sure we were prepped for our respective events this year.

Ian Atherton and Iain Dredge

Everyone needs a Dredgey (Iain) and an Athers (Ian). These two are core members of OMRT and the bedrock of any enterprise they get involved in. Their help in getting back from both Challenger events and saving Lizzie lots of grief needs acknowledging. They’re also Spine veterans themselves and familiar faces at the A62 crossing at Standedge. If these guys have your back then you’re bomb proof…

Paul Stapleton on the left in 2023

Paul Stapleton and I buddied up early on in the 2023 Winter Sprint and couldn’t have been more compatible. Since then, he’s become a great friend and as you might read later, was there for me during a rough time towards the end of the route.

Steve and Amy are the best next door neighbours of all time. Bonus is they’re good friends too and me and Steve are partners in many sports crimes! On all three events they’ve promised (and delivered!) one of their five star roast dinners on completion. That’s the kind of motivation you need when spirits are low and shouldn’t be underestimated…

Reserving the top spot for my wife and all-round rock Lizzie – no-one could have done more support wise than this lass. Happy letting me disappear into the hills at a moments notice, often at night, to run around after me in the car and not give me a moments grief about an obsession that could be viewed by many as selfish. As the occasion of the race drew nearer, she didn’t bat an eyelid when parcels arrived almost daily containing gear acquired to shave weight and ‘guarantee’ a finish! It’s also her birthday during Spine week and we’d usually go away to celebrate for a few days – that’s willingly been sacrificed to back me up in all manner of ways these last two years.

The lovely Lizzie

Lizzie booked a cosy little apartment in the centre of Hawes when we saw how rough the weather looked – prior to that we were going to van camp but driving the 3.5 tonner back in the snow would have been stressful for her. So, we chucked ourselves, kit and Gyp the collie into the Land Rover and headed up the day before kit check to have a little bit of chill time together.

Sunday’s kit check went fine – the Montane Trailblazer 30 pack with water and food weighed around 9.5 kg which was a kilo less than the previous year. This is where extra spending, plus the generosity of manufacturers such as Scarpa UK, Montane (the race’s sponsor), Sidas UK and Bridgedale had made a difference and why the expense of the entry is only part of the financial outlay for each competitor.  The weather and ground conditions forecast had made me beef up the minimum spec of the kit list and put in proper micro spikes, extra layers and a better glove/mitt system. Once that was over, we could relax till early the next morning and the start…

One major difference between the Challenger North and South apart from the distance was the unknown factor. Living in Marsden, virtually ‘on’ the Pennine Way, meant that a lot of playtime over the years had been spent on the moorland between Edale and Hawes. So I knew virtually all of the Challenger South route and terrain in advance and how to deal with it. The opposite was true now, where apart from a Herriot Way training foray with fellow Spine event entrants David Riley, Andy Morley, Jonny Ulett and Richie Banks which included Great Shunner Fell, the bulk of the route was unknown territory. To my mind, that was a good thing and made the endeavour even more of an adventure.

Gary Binns and myself at the start line

We got to the start for tracker fitting at seven in the morning and met Gary Binns, an avid Spine competitor from near Penistone. We’d met the year before and agreed to share at least a few miles this time to see how we got on. Gary’s brother Les is well known on the scene and has not only climbed Everest but is also entered in the 2025 Arctic Spine Race. He saw us off as we crossed the start line feeling strong and headed up Great Shunner Fell and into the clag.

Really quickly, it was obvious that micro spikes were a must, so we banged ours on as all around us folk were slipping and sliding. It’s a mystery to me as to why people soldier on so long before inevitably donning them. The terrain varied from sheet ice to big drifts to rapidly thawing deep bogs – the ultimate Spine nightmare! However, the combination of Scarpa’s super grippy Ribelle Run Kalibra G (gaitered) shoes and the ever game changing Kahtoola Microspikes managed to tame this year’s ridiculously difficult ground conditions to a fair degree…

Scarpa’s excellent Scarpa Ribelle Run Kalibra G with internal ‘Boa’ lacing

We knew from reports of the Challenger South event that progress over the high ground was going to be slow and difficult. So pacing was important – it’d be really easy to blow up on the first couple of climbs and have to retire. That was proved a few hours later when after reaching Tan Hill, several competitors left the race. After the most expensive, tepid half cup of tea ever, we pushed on into the afternoon – Gary was going well and we felt like a decent team. The terrain North of Tan Hill to the A66 was diabolical snow-covered bogland and we were in and out of large holes often covered by ice that wouldn’t weight bear. But so far, all was looking good and we were making reasonable time. And then the wheels nearly came off completely for me…

Just coming up to the bleak A66 crossing point, my right foot went over on itself with full weight applied, there was an almighty pain and a popping noise.  I screamed like a banshee, partly in agony but also in frustration because I knew immediately I’d sprained it. Two months earlier in the Lakes, I’d done exactly the same thing on Cat Bells and it had taken weeks to heal.

Swollen ankle at Langdon Beck

So that was it then. Day one and only 21 miles in – a total balls up. All that prep, Lizzie’s endless hard work to get me to the start – all up the Swannee. It’s hard to convey how pissed off I was in that moment. Two guys came out of the mist towards us and Gary told them the score. At that point, although the ankle was super sore, it had dulled off enough for me to know I could hobble to the A66 for a lift out. I told Gary to crack on with the two lads as there was nothing they could do for me and I didn’t want to jeopardise his chances. Being a good mate, he was very reluctant to leave but I convinced him I could look after myself and after getting me to two SST guys on the road he carried on. The guys told me they could get me evacuated by car if needed but I was starting to man up and think about something Gary had said. “If possible, after a drama, get yourself to the next checkpoint rather than abandon immediately. Once you’re out, you ain’t getting back in again.” With this in mind I asked the guys how far Langdon Beck was and they told me twenty miles. I’d deliberately brought extendable poles that could be used as a makeshift crutch so if all else failed I could still move. The other thing was that all the standing around in freezing bog water and snow seemed to have numbed the ankle so much I could now stand on it without too much pain. I told the guys I’d try to crack on and they promised to make CP1 aware of the situation. It’s a testament to their accurate assessment of my condition that they let me carry on and didn’t end things there on the A66.

Alone for the first time since the start and now in the dark, I got going. The first couple of miles were bloody tough but more immersion in the frigid bogs worked wonders and before long I was almost walking normally again. After about four miles there was respite in the form of the wondrous ladies of Clove Lodge and their morale boosting tea and soup! Fifteen minutes resting there was the tonic needed to start power limping again and four miles later and very unexpectedly, the lights of John and Gail’s aid station at Nettlepot came into view. John soon had a brew in my hand, closely followed by a mince pie. There are so many kind folk out there supporting the runners day and night – it restores faith in humanity and makes you feel very humble.

OK, now it gets interesting for you proper Spine aficionados…

Kim Collison at Nettle Pot aid station with me in the the background

Brew in hand, I noticed a light coming down the hill towards me at speed. John said, I think that’s the full Spine race leader Kim Collison. Soon, a guy arrived looking strong but still in need of a brew and before you know it he was sitting next to me. We exchanged pleasantries and were ready to set off again at the same time. We did a few hundred metres together, at which point I found my jobbed ankle was running quite happily again on adrenaline and that starstruck feeling you get from being around someone famous!

In under a mile, we topped out on a small hill and started descending. “Fancy running a bit?” said my new companion and started trotting. Worth a try I thought and set off alongside. Amazingly, there was no issue keeping pace – in fact things felt good again for the first time in many miles. Initially I felt like a stalker intruding on someone’s privacy – I’m generally happier on my own doing stuff like this but Kim said he was happy to have company. I can honestly say that this twelve mile, three hour encounter got me re-invested in the race again, so big thanks to Kim who let’s face it, had more on his mind than some old dude with a dicky leg!

As a comic aside, at various intervals we’d come across groups of other competitors who through the tracking system, knew that Kim Collison was on their tail and were stopping to cheer him on. In one such group, I saw my buddy Gary with his two new partners and as we flashed past them, I heard a very puzzled Gary say “I’m sure that was Si!”

My new buddy and I alternated between running and fast walking up the valley from Middleton to Check Point One at Langdon Beck where staff swooped on him and after a quick high five, he was ushered into the building away from sight. His story is well documented now and I was chuffed to bits hearing later that he’d nailed the win of 2025’s most brutal Spine Race after laying the ghosts of previous years to rest.

Langdon Beck was chaotic to say the least but the Spine staff as ever were phenomenal. The nearest I’ve been to feeling like a king is at a Spine race checkpoint where your every need is anticipated and delivered. I don’t think any of us can adequately thank these angels enough…

Inside, there were so many tired and muddy racers and very little room for them to sort themselves out. Many were just sat in a sea of packs and drop bags with thousand yard stares, struggling to comprehend what to do next. I did the obvious – shoes and socks off, charging plug out and connected to phone, watch and headtorch. A guy came with food but I simply couldn’t eat at that point so went in search of a bed to lie down for an hour or two. Only floor space was available at that time, but the room was warm and although impossible to sleep, a couple of hours leg rest was had. Going back into the melee downstairs, more food was offered and this time welcomed while also putting kit back on for the next stage of the route. At this point, I spotted Gary who was also looking ready to depart and we happily teamed up again after the previous nights separation.

Finding the diversion route across fields in the dark from CP1 took some doing but pretty soon we were cracking on towards the top of Cauldron Spout. This was easy terrain for quite a few miles and a respite from the previous day. Gary looked strong and was chatty for a couple of hours but as we approached High Cup Nick his demeanour suddenly changed and to my massive surprise he started talking about retiring. As a new father to twin babies, it wasn’t just a physical battle he was fighting, it was also the strain of missing his family at a time when he felt they needed him most. I tried to cheer him up but after a while he was adamant he was finishing at Dufton and rang both his wife and brother Les to let them know the score. I could hear Les also urging him to reconsider and at least wait till Dufton, but I could tell Gary’s race was over. He was in a safe place, on easy terrain and with plenty of competitors behind so with his blessing I wished him well, gave him a hug and left him to wander down to the village and a lift home.

Dufton is a lovely village and after checking in with the Spine crew, there was a great opportunity to feed up at the excellent Post Box Pantry café before the start of the days main event – Cross Fell. After stuffing the next four hours paracetamol and codeine mix down my neck and chatting with Stuart Smith back at the check point I felt ready to take on the beast which I’d heard lots about but never been near.

I felt strong on the way out of Dufton and curiously free of any responsibility to anyone now I was on my own. It’s the way I often prefer to be in the mountains – headphones on and the right music playing to motivate and distract from the discomfort of sore joints and feet.

The summit of Cross Fell as the sun set

There was a slight navigational balls up climbing Green Fell but after that, progress was swift once the almost endless plateau from Knock Fell to Cross Fell was reached. Ground conditions were now at that half way house of part frozen, part thawing and there were a few excursions through the ice into thigh deep bog. It was a privilege to arrive on the summit of Cross Fell just as the sun set and an inversion rolled up from the valley. After taking a few photos, it was time to descend the difficult ground down to the oasis of Greg’s Hut and John Bamber’s famous Chilliwack noodles.

Hats off to John and his team who live up at the remote hut right through the duration of the race. The circle of tents clustered around the bothy looked like a scene from an Antarctic survey station – volunteering as Spine staff is no cop out from doing the race itself!

The six and a half mile descent down from Greg’s Hut to Garrigill is quite brutal despite being on a broken track and was to have serious repercussions on my race. Running a fair bit of the distance, I started feeling big pain to the balls of my feet – probably through water having come OVER the top of waterproof knee socks. That should have been the time to investigate and maybe break out spare socks and the wonder Gurney Goo. But you get in a rut at night where the imagined complication of stopping and taking your pack off becomes more admin than you feel you can handle.

After Garrigill, what would usually be easy riverside footpaths down the valley to Alston were in fact miles of quagmire. This meant the feet were sliding around sideways causing the skin to shear against inevitably wet socks.

Check Point Two at Alston was slightly less chaotic than Langdon Beck but still very busy with a mix of Challenger North and Full Spine racers. My drop bag looked as if it had been dropped in farm slurry but I was so knackered I really didn’t give a monkeys any more. I booked a bed for three hours but got up after two – unable again to sleep. Investigating the foot damage done the night before, it was obvious that remedial action was probably too late to stop some gruesome looking blisters developing so I whacked Compeed and KT tape over the whole mess.

Listening to Andy McNab and Luke Combs

Back on the trail again, I had high hopes that this would be a respite day – no real mountainous terrain – just rural landscapes, river valleys and farm land to traverse till Hadrian’s Wall. What a total underestimation that was! I’ve never encountered mud and soft ground so hard to travel over as that section from Alston to Slaggyford. The snow had melted so fast that what was left was a deep shoe swallowing gunge where two steps forward resulted in another step backward. But there was a morale boost part way along when a figure loomed out of the dark holding a sheepdog on a lead. Nice to see any friendly face at this time in the morning but even better when that face turned into that of my friend Ray who lives in Slaggyford! We had five minutes chat which did me the world of good after feeling massively sleep deprived since leaving Alston.

An example of the extreme kindness shown by folk en route

It was a deep relief to get onto the old South Tynedale Railway and feel solid ground again for a few miles but it was soon back to the mud again. At a road crossing on the A689 near Lambley, some absolute Samaritans had left out two boxes of provisions for Spiners. This type of kindness needs recording and was very welcome. A packet of crisps and a bottle of water later I was headed towards the nemesis they call ‘Blenkinsopp Common’. A few miles later I was also treated to meeting Ray’s wife Viv who’d found a place where the PW crossed a minor road.

Such an innocuous name and at such a low altitude it doesn’t even rate the name ‘hill’. But Blenkinsopp Common after a thaw could be the wrecking ground of Spine dreams. Boggy, off piste terrain to rival that above my home village of Marsden was plodded through, greatly aided by a meeting with Adam who manages that section of the Pennine Way and was on a inspection walk to check storm damage with his two dogs. Leaving Adam at Greenhead and after having a quick fuel at the aid station there, I was excited to be starting East along Hadrian’s Wall.

On Hadrian’s Wall with the setting sun behind

The weather at this point was beautiful and the prospect of an afternoon on the wall with its well-drained terrain was quite appealing, despite the raging pain in my feet. I was really starting to feel the love for all things Spine when once again I went over on my ankle and there was that familiar ‘pop’. All sorts of bad language emanated from my potty mouth as this time it felt more serious than the A66 episode. There was no freezing bog to calm the swelling and pain down – just miles of undulating, rocky ground and no prospect of any medical intervention for hours. Well, walking on it the previous time seemed to sort it out, so it was worth trying again. This time though, the pain was way more intense and wasn’t lessening. Was I going to have to press the panic button after all these bloody miles? After a couple of miles though, a river cut across one of the gaps in the wall at a place called Burnhead. I climbed down the bank and immersed the ankle till it went properly numb – after more codeine and paracetamol the job was done. I was confident now it’d hold till Bellingham and then we’d see.

As the sun went down over the wall, it was again possible to appreciate the wonder of the Pennine scenery. When every footstep generates sharp pain, it’s necessary to try to distract your mind away from the immediate discomfort. For many on the route, that involves banter with a companion or two but that wasn’t an option for a solo competitor. So I turned to Andy McNab, that doyen of the survival game and one of his audio books. In fact, whenever the s**t hits the fan in my outdoor life I often think, “what would Andy do now?!!!”

And now to the sleep deprivation induced dark times of the third night out…

Coming off the wall in the dark and heading North again, the terrain and navigation once again became difficult and there was a mix of bog, steep ground and miles of forest. My buddy David Riley had given me chapter and verse on the hallucinations he suffered on his full Spine races but I hadn’t experienced any on the Challenger South the previous year. Well, the North was about to make up for it! It started with ghoulish faces in rocks and quickly progressed to bushes and tree stumps morphing into people and animals as I approached, to shrink back to reality after passing. The most disturbing was seeing the crazy looking ‘banjo boy’ from the film Deliverance rear up out of a tree to run alongside for a few seconds.

My faithful trail buddy Gyp

At other stages during both night and day, I was absolutely convinced that my sheepdog Gyp was with me and I kept turning around to check his progress. Thankfully for the old boy, he was safely tucked up in his basket at home with just his twice daily excursion up Pule Hill with Lizzie to stretch his legs. Should mention that he’d done plenty of shorter training runs with me through the Autumn but has had to throttle back considerably this year at the grand old age of nearly fourteen.

It was a long night getting from the wall to Check Point Three at Bellingham and it knocked the hell out of me on the lack of sleep front. A couple of times I just lay down in the heather and power napped which generally sorted things for an hour or so. After passing a couple of SST guys after a spell in the forest, there was a section over a low hill. Being pretty confused at this point and with the battery on my Garmin Fenix long gone, I had to map read this bit and went off course. At this point I was probably wandering around in circles and had to give myself a bit of a talking to. After equilibrium was restored, there was just one more dodgy moment on a river crossing plus a biggish climb before arriving dead on my feet at the checkpoint..

Reunited with the drop bag!

Bellingham seemed pretty civilised by comparison to the two previous CP’s as there was plenty of room. However, it doesn’t have beds so after an abortive attempt to sleep on a cold wood floor I sacked it off and set off in the dark up the long ascent from Bellingham to Abbey Rigg. The temperature was still subzero and the lack of sleep was making even the simple act of one foot after the other seem impossible. At about a thousand feet above the village I made the decision that I had to lie down and sleep so I rolled my bivvy bag with mat and sleeping bag out on the frost. After ringing Spine HQ to let them know I was stopping for an hour, the phone alarm was set and I climbed in. Zonk. Out like a light until the alarm tone of Arnold the Dog jolted me back into life again.

That hour’s proper sleep was a massive tonic and I started picking up the pace by running again. Soon, I’d passed a few familiar faces such as Ralph and John who I’d seen on previous days and was starting to feel strong again in every aspect apart from the feet. Battering on towards Byrness it was actually starting to look like the finish might be possible – ‘only’ the notorious Cheviots to go till Kirk Yetholm…

Before the foot got really bad!

Byrness was a boost as the staff were awesome. Food and drink were consumed and the medics had a look at my shredded feet. They admitted there wasn’t much they could do now for them but whacked more KT tape on to hopefully do the last twenty six miles.

Climbing up onto the Cheviots in great weather again raised my spirits, particularly since I met John and Ralph again and enjoyed their excellent company for a couple of miles. Then I pulled ahead by running and just before Hut 1 came into view, night fell. Squeezing into Hut 1 for a brew and dried meal, I let Ralph and John catch up and set off ahead of me. I was confident I’d soon overhaul them again and we could maybe all finish together. But things were about to come apart…

On the climb from Hut 1 to Lamb Hill, there was a sudden, almost unbearable pain from under the left foot. No matter how carefully I put it down each step, it wouldn’t let up. At one point I thought of back tracking to the hut but decided to man up and try to block it out with more pills. I got maybe a mile further and then I couldn’t weight the foot at all. So out came the poles as a crutch again and some slow progress continued. My phone was on at this time although the battery was nearly dead and I saw a message from Paul Stapleton, my Spine Sprint buddy from 2023. It simply said, “Hut 1 now. Got this have we?”

I replied, “Left hut 1 but down to limp mode cos of horrendous blisters. Pain killers aren’t working so it’ll be a slow job. Struggling to do 1.5mph.”

Paul did some sums in his head and came back with this.

“1.5mph is probably fast enough to get this bad boy done. You’ve got time.”

It’s a weird feeling being out on your own in the dark on a freezing hillside and yet knowing that someone miles away (Cornwall!) has got your back! So you need to crack on and not disappoint. But after another painfully slow mile it was obvious that something had to give. This ridiculous pain had to be investigated properly and a remedy found. There was no shelter from the ever increasing wind but I put my back to it and stripped off socks and shoes. In the light of the headtorch it was apparent that there was a raw, red wound and in the middle of it, the KT tape that had been put on at Byrness had come off, rolled up and was now embedded like a toothpick sticking out of the sticky flesh. Loads of dead skin matter was also stuck in there and the act of putting body weight on the whole shebang was causing the issue.

A couple of days prior to starting, I’d bought my last item of kit, a tiny Swiss Army knife called an Classic SD Allox. This now became an indispensable instrument of surgery and was absolutely instrumental to me finishing. As an ex foot health care professional, I never thought I’d be carving up my own foot but after excising the tape, some skin and a bit of flesh to reduce the pressure, I put the soaking socks back on followed by the shoe. Now was the test, to stand up…

Amazing! The pressure had gone and the pain level was now only the same as the other foot – well bearable. I got another ping on the phone from Paul.

“You OK big guy?”

“Had to take some skin away with knife – moving again…”

“Yes. Go get it now fella!”

I phoned Lizzie to tell her not to worry. She’d been dot watching right through the night and was nervously wondering why progress had stopped in the middle of nowhere.

There was now a vicious little descent to Hut 2 where a quick brew was waiting and the usual fantastic encouragement from the hardy staff. I have to admit, I thought it was all over bar the shouting at this point but that wasn’t the case…

On the way in the dark again, the climb up to the summit of the Schil at nearly two thousand feet seemed interminable. And what’s crazy is I was convinced I’d been there before – it was like I knew every twist and turn of the route. But Kim was talking about hallucinations three days earlier and said that déjà vu was a common experience too during sleep deprivation.

All the way up the Schil and down the other side, I ‘knew’ the route. But I couldn’t have because I’ve never been there before! The wind strength on the exposed slopes must have been hitting seventy miles per hour and made my already wobbly progress even slower. Descending down the other side of The Schil, I tried to open a gate but it was pinned shut by the wind and I couldn’t manage it. After climbing the fence with difficulty, there was now just a long morale sapping trog down a narrow valley which seemed to go on for ever. At one point I was swearing at the top of my voice at the unreasonableness of having to do this last bit – why was it necessary?

Just when I thought the soles of my feet couldn’t put up with any more, headlights appeared, and with them a sight for sore eyes! It was my buddies Athers and Dredgey from Oldham MRT in a truck. “Just over a mile now Si – follow the road…”

The very last comic cut from the whole episode now kicked in. I’d seen headtorches behind me and got paranoid I was being caught (like it mattered!). So I started running, ignorant of the fact that the road was rising steeply uphill. After the guys had driven past, I speeded up and then peeked behind. Bloody hell, they’re right on my shoulder now – cheeky sod! Running even faster now and ignoring the blinding misery of the sore feet, I was convinced that this interloper to my solo effort was going to pip me to the post. Round a corner lay Kirk Yetholm and the finish arch. Now I was running as fast as an old gimmer with shredded feet will ever run and as I crossed the line I looked behind to see… …Nothing!

A skeleton crew were up to meet me – given the antisocial hour, I was grateful to see anyone to be honest! The photographer asked me to make the traditional kiss to the wall but I didn’t feel I’d earned that right having just completed part of the Spine route. Maybe one day there’ll be the chance to try the full deal and then we’ll see…

So, there it goes, the Winter Spine MRT Challenger North. If you’ve read through this then you’ve probably endured more than I did but I wanted to get the experience down on paper before the memories faded.

Breakfast at Katie’s Kitchen after getting back to Marsden

The boys did a stellar job lifting me home and the only lasting fallout health-wise are the bruised, swollen and blistered feet. Not too bad a price to pay for a very unique experience…

Kudos is massively due to two colleagues in the team who also completed their respective events. Ruth Topham made a really strong finish in the Sprint, and the well known Colin Green came into Kirk Yetholm after nearly 162 hours of effort to put the full Winter Spine route to bed.

Quite a few folk have also asked about the kit used on the event – being an ex professional gear freak I’ve detailed it in another post at the link here.

 

Osprey Packs Talon 33 rucsac review

I’ve had an early version of this very popular pack for well over ten years now and it’s my go to rucsac for mountain walking days in all seasons bar full winter. The thing most immediately noticeable is its light weight of just over a kilo – remarkable given the array of features it sports.

The Talon 33 is a traditionally designed pack in that it top loads – most other sizes in the Talon series utilise zips for access. For me, a zip is potentially just another thing to fail – a strapped top lid is foolproof and durable. Many modern technical packs these days don’t feature traditional side pockets to keep them compact in shape and the Talon 33 reflects that but has a large stretch stash pocket on the front of the pack and smaller mesh ones on each side. The first is great for stuffing a shed clothing layer into for easy access when you cool off and I’ve used the side ones for my Kahtoola Microspikes and to keep poles in place although they will need covers on the spikes.

I generally use a hydration system – choice for the last ten years has been Source’s excellent 2 litre Widepac unit although Osprey themselves offer their own brand items. Storage in the rucsac for such systems is unique in that they reside essentially outside of the main body of the pack and access to clean and fill is easier than any other rucsac I’ve ever used.

The harness is micro adustable for every back size although you do need to initially pick from either a Small/Medium or Large/Extra Large. Fine tuning after that is achieved with a very clever floating shoulder system which velcros into the position of your choice and then stays silent and immovable. There’s just one compartment in the main body of the pack – I use an Exped pack liner to guarantee that my contents are kept waterproof. However, on the lid, there are two zipped pockets – one on top and one hidden underneath. These are superb for essentials such as snack bars, a head torch, midge repellent, first aid kit, hat and gloves etc – ie, the things you might need to get at quickly. Once again, I use a smaller Exped liner to protect the the top lid pocket. You can buy ‘waterproof’ rucsac covers but I’m not a huge fan as rain can still find its way in around the area next to your back and they can flap badly in the wind.

The pack now comes with a clever walking pole carrying system to allow you to deploy them without stopping to remove the pack – my version is older so came without this. Even so, carrying poles conventionally and an ice axe if required is catered for with twin loops at the bottom of the pack and shockcord securing devices at the top. In reality, I use the side compression straps and one of the stretch side pockets to secure a pair of poles – cover the sharp tips of the poles with a small sleeve of inner tube rubber and that’s a great carrying system.

The comfort level of the pack is very high with anatomically excellent shoulder straps and hip belt – weight is distributed well between them. However, being so lightweight and devoid of a frame it’s very dependent on you packing well as any lumps in contact with your back will be felt – particularly if you don’t have the buffer of a hydration pack. When sized properly and packed sensibly, I can honestly say that I’ve never had a more comfortable pack and have carried it for long distances with fairly heavy loads on occasion. Perspiration where contact is made with the back of the pack is handled decently by a breathable foam without the need for an air gap type frame.

The trade off for the pack’s light weight is that the outer material isn’t quite as durable as those rucsacs of twenty to thirty years ago that some folk will still be using. If you treat your pack super hard then a heavier, more basic model might suit you better. But I’ve walked, run and climbed with mine and despite looking a bit scruffy now, it’s coped very well.

There are many other clever features to the pack – I’ve included a link to Osprey’s website so you can check them out in more detail. The capacity works well for long days on the mountain when extra safety kit and clothing might be carried – I often pack a 30 metre thin rope and 2 man survival shelter for more technical terrain and the pack swallows them with ease along with the usual mix of hiking kit. Some might think the price is high for a day pack – I personally think that for the technicality and function offered it’s very reasonable and treated fairly should last many years.
I own a couple of other Osprey packs which are specific models for ski touring and multiday back packing. The quality is second to none and provided you can navigate the fairly complex array of different models and sizing advice on their website, you should find a fit that’s secure, comfortable and distributes load effectively.

My faithful Talon 33 is looking a bit second hand these days after many years of abuse. But if I do replace it, it’s likely to be with another one – a testament to a cleverly designed and well built piece of kit…

Click here for more information.

Scott Supertrac 3 trail shoe review

I bought my first set of Scott trail shoes over seven years ago and right from the off they felt better than anything I’d run in before. Because of injuries resulting in damaged ligaments and shortened muscle/tendon groups I can no longer get on with minimally cushioned, low drop running footwear such as the Inov8 shoes I’ve used in previous years. In fact, they’ve considerably worsened the problems I have although on people with a different physiology they can be superb.

That original set of Kinabalu Supertracs are still going, albeit looking a bit bald on the tread! They’ve since been superseded by an extensive family of Supertrac shoes – I’ve already had a couple of pairs of Supertrac 2’s and am now on the version 3 model.

Shoe reviews can never be totally objective since what fits and suits one person may not work for another. The first thing I found with the Supertrac series is that the lasting (foot shape) is reasonably universal so will fit quite a variety of foot types if the lacing is adjusted correctly. There’s more volume (width) than previously used moorland fell shoes such as Salomon’s Speedcross and a more boxy (roomier) toebox. Size seems to run true – some manufacturers footwear needs an adjustment up or down but not Scott’s.

I’ve bought two pairs half a size apart – one for winter use with waterproof and insulated socks and the smaller pair for summer. The heel fit is secure despite this extra volume and there’s enough malleability in the heel counters and ankle trim to mold well around differently shaped rear foot areas.

The Supertrac’s have a very constructed feel to them – similar to a conventionally cushioned and structured road shoe, so feel very stable. For a highly mobile or weak foot type (either genetically or through injury), this provides a very reassuring level of support and impact absorption and for me is essential these days.

I’d often looked at Hoka’s trail shoe offerings and now have a pair of Speedgoats which have their much publicised mid rockered sole unit. The Scott Supertrac 3 doesn’t feel dissimilar to be honest, you experience that rolling/propelling effect which is slightly alien to start with but quickly becomes unnoticeable and indeed advantageous. Those folk with pain or fusion problems affecting their big toe (hallux limitus etc.) will appreciate the stiffer midsole which demands less flexion from the offending toe joint.

The main difference between the two shoes is the level of grip – the Supertrac’s outsole is more aggressive and works really well in Pennine mud. The Hoka is better on harder pack trails – I tend to use it as a lightweight summer walking shoe rather than for running.

The Pennine terrain I live in is harsh for any footwear and the only criticism I can level at the Supertrac 3 is the lack of reinforcement around the big and little toe joints (1st and 5th MTPJ) which have resulted in the first signs of wear presenting in these areas and eventually in holes appearing. Once there’s a hole, it’s not the end of the shoe but I’d say they’d have a longer lifespan in less demanding environments to those of the Peak District.

However, advice from Scott is to try the more expensive but tougher Supertrac Ultra RC which is a shoe I’ll be trialling in a month or two. Fit, support and outsole remain the same but it’s a slightly heavier, more robustly engineered model with exactly the kind of reinforcing rand I’m looking for. A bit of extra weight in my opinion isn’t an issue although I appreciate some will be chasing top results and times in events where excess grams can count.

So to sum up, for those requiring support, stability and good grip for serious mountain running terrain couple with some cushioning and heel lift to alleviate Achilles tendon stresses, these could well be the shoes for you with maybe the harder wearing option of the Ultra RC version as first choice for high abrasion areas.

POSTSCRIPT: After now running several hundred miles in the Ultra RC version of the Supertrac, I can vouch for their durability. I was a finisher in both the Montane Winter Spine Sprint and Challenger South races and used the Ultra RC in both of them. They coped really well with the difficult conditions encountered on the Pennine Way in January. The link below is for this more durable model which in my opinion is the one UK winter trail runners should go for over the Supertrac 3.

Click here for more information.

Scarpa Mescalito approach shoe review

I’m a big fan of approach type footwear and tend to wear this type of shoe both on and off the hill. Prior to discovering the Scarpa Mescalito a few years ago, I’d been mainly wearing Haglof’s excellent Vertigo – they were tough and being Goretex lined, very weatherproof. But they were never super comfortable due to the stiff sole unit and thick, fairly inflexible leather upper. Like a heavy leather boot, they needed wearing a lot before they softened and moulded to the individual foot – even if carefully fitted.

When production of the Vertigo ended, I looked around for something suitable for similar every day use. Mountainfeet already sold the Mescalito and feedback had been very positive. I was initially hesitant about trusting a non-membrane shoe to keep the puddles at bay – what swayed me to try them was the supreme comfort of the fit. The upper is a thermo-embossed and malleable suede which hugs the foot without ‘bagging’ (stretching) and has lacing right down to the toe for precision fitting like a climbing boot. You can wear them slack around town or work but really crank the fit up for technical trail walking or scrambling.

The Vibram Dynamis sole unit is flexible longitudinally for both comfort and placement against rock, yet torsionally supportive to aid foot stability. Grip is good on the majority of paths although not aggressive enough for really muddy conditions – at this point you’d likely be in a pair of walking boots anyway though…

The Vibram Megagrip outsole is made from a high performance yet durable rubber compound and works really well on rocky surfaces. The term ‘approach shoe’ was coined years ago to denote a shoe you’d walk to the base of a climb in before changing to more technical footwear. I’ve been confident enough with this shoe to scramble up to grade 3 and even do an easy impromptu solo climb or two with when walking by our local crag with Gyp the dog.

Durability is good for such a light and comfortable shoe. Repeated dog walking in peaty conditions saw my first pairs outsole part company with the midsole in a couple of places after a year but that was soon remedied with some ‘Shoe Goo’ and my two latest pairs haven’t had the same issue.

The Mescalito has a light but very tough polyurethane rand protecting the upper from scuffs and scrapes – this also seems to give the shoe great protection from water ingress when walking though shallow streams and puddles.

Despite this model not having a ‘waterproof’ membrane, Scarpa now produce a Goretex lined version for those that are going to be serial puddle paddlers! For me, the additional ventilation and breathability that comes with a non-membrane upper is worth the small risk of water ingress and I just make sure my foot placement in wetter weather is a bit more careful than usual. To be honest, during the many hundreds of miles I’ve walked in these shoes, I haven’t had wet feet – if conditions are boggy then it’s generally time for heavier duty footwear or maybe waterproof socks…

These are my go to shoe for virtually anything that doesn’t require a full on boot and I wear them casually too – last night’s party at a neighbour’s house being the latest example!

Fitwise, they are fairly versatile – this is partly due to the relaxed nature of the suede upper and the fact you can customise the tension of the laces to suit different foot shapes. They’re still unlikely to be the best option for a very high volume (wide) foot but I think Scarpa’s choice of last for this shoe is a clever compromise between technical precision and a reasonably universal fit.

There’s one last reason why I love this shoe and it’s pure vanity! It’s a great looking piece of footwear and works as well in the pub as it does on the hill. Not the cheapest product out there admittedly, but in my view well worth the outlay for such a versatile and technically capable bit of kit…

Click here for more information.

Fenix HM65R-DT head torch review

Anyone who’s followed the Mountainfeet Facebook page for enough years will probably have picked up on my brand loyalty to Petzl – particularly where it concerns their head torch product. But along has come a manufacturer to severely test that allegiance, if not break it. That said, my inventory of Petzl head torches are dear to me and will still be getting plenty of usage when applicable and also carried as light weight spares…

Having been training more and more at night, I’ve been finding that my current Petzl torch, the Swift RL, has suffered with shortish battery life. This is particularly noticeable during the colder months of the year when the battery pack is exposed to low temperatures. On a recent round of the Yorkshire Three Peaks, I replaced the battery three times in under eight hours, despite using the torch on only its middle power setting.

A bunch of outdoor colleagues have sworn by the Welsh manufacturer Fenix UK, so I contacted their marketing officer Jamie Bowen who was incredibly helpful and advised that the latest version of their trail running specific head torch, the HM65R-DT would be my best bet. Several friends active in the mountaineering world have the tried and tested HM65R model which differs slightly and has a full ‘around and over the head’ strap system unlike the headband only DT version. It’s worth pointing out that now (as of December 2024), there’s a new version of the torch called the HM65R-T v2 which is pictured and looks slightly different to the one reviewed here.

Key to my needs is the HM65R-DT’s battery which is removable and rechargeable both in and out of the torch provided you buy the additional smart charger. It’s a 3400 mAh lithium-ion button top battery that looks like a huge AA type and apart from being over 1000 mAh higher in capacity than the Swift battery, it’s cheap to replace or buy more spares. There are also two 3500 mAh versions available, one of which can be connected directly to a regular phone charger or power pack. Fenix claim a 12 hour life for the torch while running at a constant 400 lumens and this seems to be backed up by various unrelated reviewers. Given that 400 lumens is more than adequate for most running and hiking needs, I’m expecting to get a full winter’s night’s activity completed on about one and a half batteries with ease. To be honest, I’ve used it on the moors quite happily set to just 130 lumens with the odd burst of 400 and 1300 lumens to spot distant features, so I can easily imagine a full night with no need for a battery change.

This brings me on to the head torch itself. First impressions are of its almost industrial build quality – it’s highly unlikely that you’ll break this beastie in a hurry! Slight downside to this durability is the unit’s weight compared to the smaller and lighter Swift but it’s something you seem to get used to quite quickly. The body is built from magnesium alloy and the whole torch is IP68 dust and waterproof rated – a very reassuring quality for UK use, as is its two metre drop resistance. The Petzl Swift RL is IPX4 – a lower rating that doesn’t cover total immersion from say, being dropped in a stream.

Looking to the front of the Fenix unit, you’ll see two distinct and separate lamps. This is where it takes a little time to get your head around what’s what, but bear with me…

Fenix don’t go in for adaptive or reactive lighting such as features on several Petzl models and to be honest, this is no great loss in my humble opinion. The main purpose behind such technology is to save battery life by attempting to never oversupply more brightness than is needed. In reality, I still find myself fiddling around with the Swift’s various settings to get an optimum beam, so it hasn’t done away with the human button input entirely. This brings me back to the Fenix which provides two very unique light beam patterns and strengths from the different sized LED’s to fine tune the torch for all situations and terrains.

What you get in the HM65R-DT are separate spotlight and semi spotlight beams. I find Fenix’s description of the two beams a bit confusing but don’t worry, it doesn’t detract from the function of the torch in the slightest. But to me, a spotlight would be a narrow, focused beam and a semi spotlight more of a flood light with a wider angle. If you read Fenix’s website blurb, they describe it as the other way around – at least to my mind. So, there’s a fairly narrow angle, quite orangey coloured light running in three increments of 5, 130 and 400 lumens. You might ask what use to man or beast is five lumens but in this mode, it’ll last you till your hair turns grey or to get you home and is also good for more covert work in the absence of any red LED’s.

The idea of tinting this LED a warm, slightly orange colour, (what they call warm white) is to allow the light to penetrate rain, snow, mist and fog better without bouncing back. In practice, when bounce back or cold breath flare becomes an issue, I usually just hand hold the torch at waist level – a handy tip if you didn’t already know it! But another spin off benefit is that you always know which of the two LED’s is lit – just from the colour. Paradoxically though, it is possible to combine beams – supposedly for the best of both although in practice I don’t really see the advantage.

The other lamp (bright white) runs from 130 through 400 to a rabbit roasting 1300 lumens. This would be what I would consider more of a flood beam as it has a wide peripheral reach. I suspect Fenix call it a spotlight because it has a very defined edge. On their previous but still available trail running model, the HM65R-T, this beam is even wider angled. Fenix have reduced it on the HM65R-DT and I think it’s bang on for open moorland and enclosed lanes alike. The 1300 lumens setting should probably be looked on as an occasional use only asset – partly because of the inevitable drop in battery life and also because even the best quality high lumen LED’s generate a lot of heat. Consequently, the best torches (this one included) have circuitry built in to drop the power down after a period of time to prevent overheating occurring. However, this is a brilliant (pardon the pun!) weapon to have should you be searching for a navigational feature or stile on the far side of a field. Whilst talking technically, this head torch utilises circuitry that runs every brightness mode bar the lowest at its full power until the battery dies. This is far better than cheaper torches that just fade gradually as the battery weakens – the only downside is you need to monitor the battery situation to avoid being left high and dry! That said, the likelihood is that even after there’s no juice to fuel the 130 lumens and above beams, you’ll probably still get a few hours at the emergency five lumen level – will report back soon on that…

Switches for the two lamp beams are separate and sit either side of an easy to read battery level indicator. Some have mentioned the buttons being slightly fiddly but I’d rate them as more positive in feel than the Petzl Swift RL and the Petzl Reactik’s I also own. The deal maker for me over the Swift is the button locking feature to make sure they don’t switch on accidentally in your pack. The Swift has a sliding button affair which three times now has unlocked itself with movement in my rucsac, resulting in flat batteries. The Fenix uses an excellent system that involves pressing both buttons together to lock the torch in the off mode. This is a bigger deal than some might think, many years ago, a friend had a non branded LED torch cause a serious fire in his house through coming on in a pack!

Comfort and ease of adjustment is always a big part of what makes a merely good head torch excellent. In this, Fenix have gone ballistic in one sense of the word to provide a wide, comfortable, reflective and breathable headband which has a one handed BOA adjusting gizmo such as is now tried and tested on certain mountaineering boots instead of conventional laces. As fed back to Fenix, I have twin thoughts on this – certainly, for snugging up the headband around your head gear in fine increments it works fantastically. And the adjustment/release wheel is quick and easy to operate with gloves. But I’d have liked to see an option for a simple, slide adjusted headband too – sometimes in my line of work and play I have to repeatedly take off and put back on a head torch. The BOA system relies on a strong twine like cord running over the elastic headband and once in position isn’t noticeable against the head as the main strap cushions it perfectly. But it needs readjusting every time it’s re-donned and that’s a faff when doing it repeatedly. Maybe this is something Fenix could either offer as an option or even enclose with the torch so the buyer could choose?

Battery replacement is a little more fiddly in the field than the Swift but then again, I’m not expecting to be doing it very often! For regular use, the supplied battery will be all most people need for their activities and when back at base, the head torch as a whole can be plugged in to your favourite USB wall charger using the supplied USB C cable. No need to remove the battery at all for most applications. But if like me, you might be needing light for 14 to 15 hours during winter nights, spare batteries such as the original cost only £22 – a far cry from the Petzl Swift’s spare battery RRP of £55 or thereabouts! But a tip from me would be to buy the slightly more powerful (and expensive at £27) Fenix 3500 mAh USB Micro battery which can be charged using your regular phone charger or power pack and then carried as a spare.

To summarise, I’m completely sold on the Fenix HM65R-DT and it’s going to be my go-to head torch now for many activities. Don’t let the ‘trail running’ label on the product prevent you buying it if hiking only is your thing, although you could look at the standard HM65R also. Price is competitive at an RRP of £110.95 for such a high spec product and it’ll likely serve you for many years. There’s also an engraving service for £2.99 so you can have your name and mobile etched on the body in case of losing it.

So, loads of positives to fire you up, and the one minor niggle in my mind is the lack of a simple head band as an option for certain uses.

Click here for more information.

Scarpa Spin ST trail shoe review

I’ve worn Scarpa footwear of various types for forty years – my first serious pair of boots were the then brand new, but now legendary, SL’s. Since then I’ve used their classic mountaineering model, the Manta, the lightweight and technical Charmoz, freeride ski boots such as the Typhoon and for mooching around and approach work, their brilliant and comfortable Mescalito shoes (reviewed elsewhere on this page). Scarpa use many different lasts (foot shapes) throughout their footwear range which can often mean that if one doesn’t suit you then another will. For that reason, careful assessment by an experienced boot fitter will help quickly cut through to the appropriate models.

Over the last few years, Scarpa have been gaining a significant toehold (pardon the pun!) in the trail running sector, resulting in the design of a few models that very much suit the UK market and our unique terrain and conditions. Being located at the Northern end of the Peak District, our upland areas of heather, grasses, peat bog and gritstone are a challenge for any footwear and a great place to test new products to the limit.

My first experience of a Scarpa trail running shoe has been with the Spin ST, a nice looking model that was new for the 2023 Autumn season and a sibling to three other products in the Spin series of trail running footwear.
Understanding where the Spin ST fits in to this range is important as to whether it’s going to be the shoe for you. The other models are orientated towards the medium to long distance sphere of activity on firmer ground and as such are high on cushioning for repeated impact over a long period of time with squarer toe boxes. The ST is marketed as a more precise fitting, performance-based shoe for shorter distance routes or races involving technical and demanding terrain. Accordingly, the toebox is fairly snug – this isn’t a shoe for a high-volume foot! But what really sets it apart from its relations is the aggressive 7mm deep lugged and sticky outsole – a big hint towards the terrain it works brilliantly on!

I can’t in all honesty say that the Spin is a perfect fit for my widish forefeet – I had to jump up a size from normal just to take the pressure from the big toe joint. But that’s footwear for you – just ‘cos a shoe suits your mate, it doesn’t mean you’ll get on with it! But given I wasn’t going to be in them for hours at a time, I figured I could still give the Spin ST’s a few decent test outings.

My initial thoughts were, “is it reinforced enough for Pennine use?” It’s been designed to be light and that often means durability is sacrificed. But if you look carefully, you’ll see the likely areas of pressure and abrasion are well protected and the mesh upper is a tight weave unlikely to damage easily. That said, there’s plenty of opportunity for the shoe to drain of water after a stream crossing or puddle immersion.

This shoe balances well between enough structure to support the foot and the need for feeling the ground through the sole. As such, it’s quite flexible but without feeling too minimal and the designers haven’t gone overboard with cushioning. Yet there’s still enough to take the sting out of the occasional heavy heel landing and ample torsional and longitudinal firmness for off-piste stability.

For an old boy like me, the need for a shoe to pile downhill fast passed me by many years ago. But everyone will appreciate the awesome traction and grip of this shoe for descending – whether on mud, wet grass, slimy slabs, fresh snow or rock. The compound of the Vibram outsole is stickier than anything I’ve tried previously and as long as you’re not doing big miles on the tarmac to get to the off road stuff, shouldn’t wear too quickly. Our biggest nemesis on the tops around Marsden are the miles of slabs laid on the Pennine Way that when damp can feel like running on ice in most footwear. I’ve used screw in studs on other shoes in the past but the Spin ST’s are surprisingly secure once scrubbed in a bit.

Laces are traditional crossed affairs but the eyelets they run through pull on webbing woven into the upper to snug the shoe up around the mid foot and heel. There’s also a simple but cunning lace lock device that removes the need for tying a bow and a little pocket to stash the lace ends into.

Visually, the shoe looks a little boot like because of the soft Lycra cuff enveloping the lower part of the ankle bones. This provides some welcome protection from knocks and abrasions and will help keep debris out for most although with my stick thin ankles there was a tiny gap. You don’t feel the ankle cuff in any negative way – the shoe still feels super light and nimble.

The heel to forefoot drop is 4mm – just enough to take some stress off the Achilles tendon whilst still feeling in touch with the ground. I think those in the minimal or nil drop camp could still be happy with the reasonably natural sensation that comes through the shoe from the terrain, whilst anyone needing a degree of cushioning is still well catered for. There’s a basic foam insole fitted as standard which I replaced with a pair of Sidas 3Feet Run Protect insole as in all my running shoes.

So, to sum up; if I was twenty years younger and running shortish yet technical mountain and fell routes at speed then these would be a great go to shoe just for their immense grip alone. They hold the foot incredibly well when laced precisely and are light enough for the gram counters to race in at a serious level.

Folk wanting more impact protection on firmer surfaces over longer distances, will find the Spin Ultra and Infinity models well worthy of consideration. They feature much more cushioning and in the case of the Ultra, a 6mm heel to forefoot drop to reduce impact stresses still further.

For those like me who are looking for that elusive mid to long distance winter shoe that can protect, grip, insulate and cushion, then Scarpa’s Ribelle Run Kalibra ST and G models are winning favour in events such as the Winter Spine Series races. I’m currently on crutches after a mishap a couple of weeks ago but once recovered, there’s a shiny new pair of Kalibra ST’s waiting to be given the full Pennine test treatment.

Click here for more information.

Heuristic traps in decision making

The phrase ‘heuristic trap’ occasionally rears its head in conversations on mountain activity decision making. It’s likely we’ve all at some stage fallen into one or more of the traps, hopefully to survive and learn from it.

Good decision making is often acquired by experience rather than being formally taught, but here for those who are interested is an excellent article by Mountaineering Scotland on safely conducting days in the mountains along with an explanation of the phrase…

Click on the graphic below to read the article in full.

Mountaineering Scotland

Mountainfeet
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping us to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.